Kip McKeanAug 22nd, 2010 | By admin | Category: Church Splits, Featured, Kip McKean, marking
Interesting article analyzing McKean’s claims over the years regarding his resignation from the ICOC.
McKean continues to build his new kingdom based entirely on how he built his last kingdom. Here’s a side-by-side comparison as to how he’s building….and for that matter, how it will end.
August 31, 2008 – Article – Clearing Up the Confusion – McKean
“Recently, Steve Johnson and the remaining elders in Portland, Oregon, stated their autonomy and desire to, “Have no man as a leader over them.” Sadly, with these decisions, they have separated themselves from the Sold-out Discipling Movement. Yet, we wish them well. Two months ago, with this decision seemingly eminent, Tony Untalan, one of the two original elders of Portland, and Michael Williamson, a regional leader for years in Portland, moved their families and encouraged other Portland disciples to move to any of the churches in the new movement! Out of this confusion, a small remnant group was formed in Portland. It is overseen by Jeremy Ciaramella of Eugene, Oregon, and is called the Portland International Christian Church.”
August 29, 2008 – Article on ICOCHotNews – Portland ICC church breaks away from Kip McKean and the Soldout Discipling Movement.
August 10, 2008 – Sermon – Think on These Things from Steve Johnson in the Portland ICC church addressing some of the rumors about a possible split from the Sold-Out Discipling Movement
March – The McKeans move to Los Angeles to lead the City of Angels International Christian Church – Inaugural service is scheduled for May 6, 2007
Portland appoints McKean as World Missions Evangelist
- November 19, 2007 – Editorial… A HotNews Response to Raul Moreno by Mike Taliaferro
- “Raul Moreno became connected with Kip McKean and the Portland Movement several years ago. Members of that movement are called to recruit heavily from the ICOC congregations. When Raul tried to lead his ICOC church in Santiago, Chile, into Kip’s new movement, he was disciplined for being divisive. The vast majority (90%) of the membership stayed in the ICOC when he left. He recently wrote an editorial to defend his divisive behavior. We take issue with several of his statements.
- October 21, 2007 – Raul Moreno responds with his comments about recent events regarding the Santiago Church
- “The three Florida evangelists proceeded to mark me and another ministry leader couple as divisive, thus disfellowshipping us. They also gave advice to those they had swayed to avoid the disciples that had continued to follow our lead. Indeed, there is a new congregation in Santiago, Chile. That church is the one that decided not to follow their leaders. They even named one of their own as their “new” leader. The congregation that I now lead is practicing exactly what I have been teaching during my entire tenure in Santiago. We have embraced the original ICOC teachings. The name of the congregation I still lead is the Santiago International Christian Church. The new church is called the Santiago ICOC only because the fourth and only dissenting couple of the leadership group was the administrator, who as president of the board, carried with him the legal rights and name of the church. Now, a month after this separation, the Santiago International Christian Church is once again thriving and starting to baptize!”
- August 27, 2007 – Santiago ICOC Church splits when local leaders join Kip’s new movement. Local Leaders marked.
- “On Sunday the Morenos met with a group of about 30 in their apartment building, while the rest of us (about 250) had a great worship in the regular facility. John Hoyt gave a meaningful communion service, his first in Spanish, and John Reus preached an inspiring sermon. We met, again, at 4:00 with the church and at 6:00 with the Bible talk leaders. At this time, both Raul Moreno and Kip McKean were marked for their divisiveness (Romans 16:17 and Titus 3:10). On Monday morning we had an inspiring congregational devotional and prayer time. Between, before and after these meetings the staff in Chile (unfortunately minus Raul and Lynda) and the group from Florida met to study, pray and organize. ” ….”In that same devotional, it was necessary for us to mark Alfredo and Alejandra Anuch, Raul’s right hand couple, for their divisiveness. It feels contradictory to mark church members, because we try so hard to keep them saved. But, we understand that the scriptures leave us no alternative, in order that the larger flock might be protected. The 250 disciples who remain in the original church have high standards of unity, love, faithfulness and devotion. This church has a great desire to reach Chile and beyond with the gospel. They are an example and an inspiration to us all.”
- February 28, 2007 – Berlin ICOC Church writes about it’s members being contacted to attend a new church being started by Kip. English Translation
- March – The McKeans move to Los Angeles to lead the City of Angels International Christian Church – Inaugural service is scheduled for May 6, 2007
- February 6, 2007 – Las Vegas ICOC response to the Portland Movement starting a new church in Las Vegas:
- January 23 – McKean launches his “official” website KipMckean.org
- January 10, 2007 – The Greater Las Vegas Church of Christ (ICOC) issues a warning about a new church being started by the Portland church in Las Vegas.
- January 2007 – Portland appoints McKean as World Missions Evangelist
Disciples Today Article – Kip McKean Starts The International Christian Churches, Roger Lamb, Publisher, and the Disciples Today Editorial Advisory Board
”McKean never acknowledged God’s discipline through the brothers’ statement. ….The message remains the same: churches not aligned with him are dead and not right with God. Though he acknowledges there are faithful disciples in other churches, according to his own words, to be in a true church you must leave your church and come be with Kip’s new fellowship of churches of only “sold-out” disciples. Seasoned leaderships from around the world, including commended brothers who have known Kip for decades have condemned these simplistic and condescending judgments regarding our family of churches.”
November 11, 2006 – Doug Arthur from the Baltimore ICOC parts ways with Kip McKean
“This brother is Kip McKean. It profoundly saddens me that we have come to this moment in time. I love and appreciate all that Kip has done for me and many of our churches. He is a man of great vision and zeal, but I couldn’t disagree with him more adamantly. I believe all we need now is faith and victorious examples to inspire one another. (That is why I’m so proud of the Greater Baltimore Church . God has blessed our faith with inspiring progress .We have witnessed dozens of baptisms and restorations and a rapidly growing attendance and contribution.)
I have been one of Kip’s closest friends for more than 25 years and I have tried hard in the last year to avert this parting of the ways. Doug Lambert and I visited Portland in May of this year to call the leadership to repent of critical and condescending remarks that were constantly being made about Churches and Christians in other places. I even went so far as to offer help in editing the Portland bulletin in an attempt to minimize these offensive comments and characterizations. Though some changes were made and Kip apologized publicly and privately, the reconciliation I had hoped for as well as the consistent change in message from Portland has not occurred. Tragically, in recent months it has become clear that these efforts were cosmetic in nature. The underlying conviction that Kip and the Portland leadership maintain is that our fellowship is collectively beyond hope and can best be used for ‘spare parts’ to be build a whole new “movement”.
November 5, 2006 – Article Partners in the Gospel Part 2
“A few weeks ago, a dear friend felt compelled to write me and in an effort to be constructively critical, offered the formula “Kip + a few disgruntled people = new church.” I admit there is truth in this charge. Many brothers and sisters unhappy with their congregations are asking me and others associated with me to help them start new churches. I see this as an improvement over staying in an existing church and being disgruntled or falling away from God. This was exactly the position I took in 1982 when we began sending men and women around the world planting new churches. Most had been converted or grafted in from churches from which they had become unhappy. So I have to agree and even advertise that if you are unhappy with where you are and cannot resolve things, come with us. We are baptizing the lost and creating a new fellowship of Christians excited about sharing their faith. If you are happy (spiritually fulfilled and your conscience is clear) in the congregation where you are now, you should stay there; seek and save the lost from that part of the Kingdom. But if you are not happy, and cannot “get happy,” perhaps you should consider joining us as we passionately strive to obey Jesus’ Great Commission to go to all nations. “
October 31, 2006 – The Bay Area Christian Church (formerly the San Francisco ICOC) emailed their congregation about an email being sent to its members inviting them to join a new church being planted with support from the Portland church.
“The support that these 3 people have received from the Portland Church of Christ is not unusual. The Portland Church of Christ has decided that anyone who does not join them in building their “new movement” is “lukewarm”. We confirmed their support of anyone who wants to plant a church anywhere with one of their evangelists today. This is unfortunate since we have been one of the only churches in the world who have not publicly condemned them even though we don’t agree with them. The only reason we are putting this information on record is because of these mass emails. “
October 22, 2006 – The Salt Lake City church which was recently planted from Portland has no longer condones the actions of the Portland churches
“As the leadership of the Salt Lake Christian Church we firmly believe God has placed us in a position as a bridge between the two sides of this argument. And it is to this end that we will continue to work. When asked to sign the unity proposal we declined, not because we thought it was a bad concept, but because we value our relationship with the Portland family of Churches and do not wish to restrict or damage our relationships. To that same end we cannot condone the conduct of the Portland Family of Churches and their split from the rest of our family. While included as part of their family, on paper, and while we will do all that we can to support them in their faith, we are disappointed that our church was included in a list of churches that are forming their own movement. We do not want to be included on any list that brings division not unity.”
Los Angels International Church of Christ publicly marks Kip McKean.
“Because of these unrepentant deceitful and divisive actions, and after careful consideration, we are publicly marking Kip McKean, the force behind these efforts, Sal Valasco, the local leader of this faction, and whoever else promotes this action with them.”
October 15, 2006 – Article – “Partners In The Gospel”
“For these reasons, after several agonizing days of prayer as well as counsel from the Portland elders and evangelists, my decision at this juncture is to start over with whoever is willing to help in building a worldwide movement for baptizing lost souls. …. if one has a conviction that you should never start a new church, then he or she should attend the Roman Catholic Church as it is the most direct link to the first century church. But we believe many ICOC congregations have drifted in “life and doctrine” to such an extent that it is time for a revolution of starting new churches composed of only sold-out disciples.”
Jun 11, 2006 – Article – A Heartfelt Apology – McKean
“I am so sorry to everyone who is striving to be a dedicated disciple of Jesus. Please forgive my arrogance and disrespect in the Portland Bulletin articles and in my Sunday sermons, which are online. I do believe there are church leaderships around the world that are trying very hard to restore the lordship of Christ and discipling.”
March 2, 2006 – The Chicago Church of Christ responds to the recent announcement that Kip McKean plans on planting a new church of “sold-out” disciples in Chicago.
“A phone call from Chris Broom of Syracuse, New York and an announcement on the web made us aware that Kip McKean and the Portland International Church of Christ in conjunction with the Central New York Church of Christ in Syracuse is preparing to plant a church in Chicago. Some of our members have been encouraged to leave our fellowship to join in this effort. While we gladly welcome any disciple of Jesus who is committed to reaching the Chicago area for Christ, we feel strongly that this action is divisive. Divisiveness destroys unity, hurts the faith of individual Christians and harms God’s kingdom. The divisive tactics being used by this group are more evidence of the continued sin that has been addressed in the past. We denounce the division caused by the actions of this group just as Paul did in Romans 16:17-19 and Titus 3:9-11.”
A new article gives a “behind-the-scenes” account as to how Kip came to the Portland church. By Jenny Lynch, 12 year member, staff member, San Francisco Church of Christ; a former church leader in the Portland Church of Christ; and Gloria Keeney, 20 year member Sacramento Metro Church of Christ
The Brothers released a 2nd letter to Kip McKean, this time signed by over 80 brothers
“From our deep concern for your soul and to protect the flock, we must continue to oppose you as long as you try to divide disciples from one another. Out of reverence for God and love for you and all of his people, we commit to obeying these Scriptures which tell us to have no further fellowship with you until you repent: I urge you, brothers, to watch out for those who cause divisions and put obstacles in your way that are contrary to the teaching you have learned. Keep away from them. For such people are not serving our Lord Christ, but their own appetites. By smooth talk and flattery they deceive the minds of naive people. Romans 16:17-18″
Concern For All the Churches – From the Portland Leadership.
Portland’s response to the Letter from the Brothers
A group of Brothers send a letter to McKean about his divisiveness.
“You have said publicly that your repented of your arrogance. At the Portland Church Builder Conference, shortly after you said you had repented of your arrogance and pride, you said, “I can fix any church.” When you were recently asked privately if you were willing to be a team player with other brothers in cooperative leadership, your response was, “You don’t understand. I am the star.”…
“Brother, we hope and believe that you would be the first to vehemently oppose the arrogance and “divisiveness in those comments if they were from anyone else but yourself. You have made known to the world your disregard for anyone’s ability to help any other church except yourself. Most mature people who have known you the best over the last 20 to 30 years are the ones who have lost confidence in your spiritual life. Instead of accepting the reasons they give for their lack of confidence (your unrepented sins), you instead turn it around on them, blame them and trust your own analysis. (Proverbs 14:12)”
The Phoenix Valley Church of Christ now warns it’s members to stay away from McKean, the Portland Church and Chris and Sonja Chloupek
“In view of the current actions of the Chloupeks, Kip and the Portland church, we as your leaders urge you to obey Paul’s admonitions quoted above from Romans 16:17: “Keep away from them.” Any fellowship or contact should be totally discontinued as of today. We are saddened to bring this matter before you, but we are totally resolved to biblically deal with divisiveness and unbiblical teachings that affect our members. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.”
The South Florida church hands out a letter to the members on Sunday, September 4
“The weak need our support and confidence, not derision or abandonment. Anyone who stirs up controversies and divisions is divisive. We pray that Kip will change and recognize the hard work and perseverance of so many who have led the churches in the good times and bad. We pray that he will not create divisions in the local churches with his rhetoric or any actions he may take in the future. We pray he will help the weak and bear with those who are struggling in their faith.”
September 6, The LA leadership is now distancing themselves from McKean,
“We, here in LA, did not believe that “The Portland Story” reflected the spirit in which the Lord desired to initiate unity. Rather than a spirit that included threats, intimidation and arrogance, we believed that our brotherhood challenges needed to be tackled by a collective plan, not one that focused on a single congregation or person as the primary source for answers.”
“Although we are committed to making disciples here in San Diego as well, it saddens us to say that his [Kip] divisive statements are clearly doing more harm than good, and we are absolutely opposed to having anything to do with it here in the San Diego Church of Christ.”
St. Louis Church warns others about McKean and their desire to NOT join the LA Unity Plan
Phoenix Church response regarding McKean and The Portland Story
Seattle church publishes an article responding to McKean and The Portland Story
“We appeal in particular to the Portland leadership group to consider and act on these observations carefully and thoroughly. We do believe that the Portland church is a zealous, happy place, but we implore them to make remedy and apologize for behavior affecting disciples beyond Portland’s borders—for disrespecting, judging, for condescension, for one-size-fits-all demeaning words, for ignoring Matthew 18 protocols in specific church situations, and to renounce reckless accusations and opinions foisted as doctrines.”
Boston Elders Response to actions of McKean and issue a warning.
“Kip’s actions are divisive and arrogant and must be opposed.”
Disciples Today website posts THE PORTLAND STORY from the Portland Jubilee with a stern warning as an introduction:
“[DT Editor’s Note: DisciplesToday.net publishes articles by brothers and sisters whom we believe want to build God’s church, not tear it down. We publish articles that are Scripture lessons on the Teaching Channel. On the Commentary channel we publish articles from people who have different points of view, but believe the same basic things about being a disciple of Jesus. We will never all agree on every approach, method or opinion. We must be mature enough to agree in Jesus and respect each other in all other areas — especially while disagreeing on opinions. In order to truly reach the world with the gospel, we must be mature enough to accept the truth from each other with grace.
Before you read articles on the Commentary Channel, we implore you to read 1 Corinthians 1-3 and Romans 14 and 15. If you can read other disciples’ viewpoints and strong convictions about opinions without judging the other person and without looking down on them, then please read, pray and ask God to use you to forge unity among us. If you cannot, we respectfully request that you not read these articles so that you will not stumble or cause others to stumble.]”
McKean draws the line in the sand at the recent Jubilee. Read The Portland Story.
“However, as of this Jubilee the Portland leadership believes it is time for a progressive “calling-out of the remnant of disciples” from dying, former ICOC Churches. For years, I have preached “one church-one city,” in other words, each city should have only one church of disciples, because if they are faithful to God, He will multiply them to evangelize not only their city but the whole region. (Acts 19:8-10) I still believe in this same principle. Sadly, it has become the practice of some former ICOC churches to break-up into geographic groups or groups of various convictions about commitment to Christ, discipling and church government. If a group asks for help to restore the foundation of sold-out disciples, we will help in any way we can. Biblically, disciples can never rebel against authority, yet as seen with David who “chose” to transfer his allegiance from the ungodly Saul to the uncircumcised Achish (1 Sam 27:1-4) one is “free to choose” whom to submit to!”
Henry Kriete continues to speak out against McKean recently.
“I believe Kip is delusional and arrogant. Doctrine aside, I believe he is a false teacher based on his ethical failures, deceitfulness and divisive spirit. I say to anyone and everyone involved with him or in the same camp as him-run for your lives!”
2004 – January – McKean interviewed in the Christian Chronicle
Salt Lake City Leaders Response to RtR III, July
McKean releases Revolution to Restoration III – From Babylon to Zion sometimes called RtR III
McKean moves to Portland, OR to lead the Portland International Church of Christ
Some ICOC Churches release “apology” letters to their congregations
Boston Globe Article “A Christian Community Falters”
Henry Kriete – Honest to God
Article about the Control Mechanisms used in the ICOC
ICOC Unity Conference – Los Angeles, California – November 15, 2002
Elders’ Response to McKean resignation
November – McKean’s announce their resignations as World Missions Evangelist and Women’s Ministry Leader and Leader of the World Sector Leaders
World Sector Leaders Response to sabbatical
World Sector Leaders response to McKean sabbatical
November 11, 2001 – LA Worship Service Transcript, McKean speaks about the sabbatical
November – The McKeans step down from leading the LA Church of Christ to take a sabbatical and work on family issues
McKean releases The 20th Century Church: REVOLUTION THROUGH RESTORATION I I sometimes called RtR II
McKean releases From Jerusalem to Rome, From Boston to Moscow – REVOLUTION THROUGH RESTORATION I sometimes called RtR I